A Slight Modification to the Hall of Fame Ballot

I didn’t really expect to be talking about the Hall of Fame so much this week, but, after doing this post earlier today, I just couldn’t help myself.

As you can see from today’s earlier post and last year’s Hall of Fame ballot, I tend to think of the Hall of Fame ballot in groups – the no-brainers, the close-calls, the nice guys, and so on. And I doubt I’m alone on this. Ask anyone what he thinks of a few of the eligible players, and you’re bound to hear this same sort of categorization in some form.

With that in mind, I thought it might be fun to redraw the Hall of Fame ballot in such a way that allowed the voter to clearly define what category each player falls under. And since these categories hardly, if ever, change from year-to-year, the basic layout of the ballot wouldn’t need to change. You can see a glimpse of the ballot below. Click on the image to see the full ballot.

(Click “Read More” to continue reading.)


The ballot is divided into six fairly obvious categories (listed below). From there, the voter is told to place each of the 33 candidates into his appropriate category. A checkbox is provided to mark whether or not that player is being voted into the Hall. The categories are:

  • “Vote for him or I will physically harm you.”
  • “He’s not Babe Ruth, but that doesn’t mean he wasn’t great…”
  • “He’s good, all right, but just how good?”
  • “O-VER-RATED!! Clap. Clap. Clap, Clap, Clap.”
  • “I liked you, but we both know you’re no Hall of Famer.”
  • “How’d this guy get on the ballot?!”

Technically, a vote is allowed for anyone in any of the categories, but some categories are clearly much more vote-friendly. I included ten spaces for each category, but there’s no hard rule against going over.

The descriptive Hall of Fame ballot is only meant for fun, of course. I don’t expect even my blogger friends to adopt it for their balloting. But I can’t think of a more fun, honest way of describing your Hall of Fame voting than with this ballot. Where else do you get to put Juan Gonzalez and Jack Morris in the “O-VER-RATED!!” category? Or Bobby Higginson in the “How’d this guy get on the ballot?!” category? You can’t get much more honest than that. I’d love to see a few others’ versions of the Descriptive Hall of Fame Ballot (mine, if you haven’t guessed, can be see if you click through).

Larry Granillo

About Larry Granillo

Larry Granillo has been writing Wezen Ball since 2008 and has dealt with such touchy topics as Charlie Brown's baseball stats and Ferris Bueller's day off. In 2010, he got the bright idea to time every home run trot in baseball; he has been missing ever since.